|
|
#1 | |
Member
|
|
|
Grok'tul, Warbringer Background Story: coming soon BASIC INFORMATION Affiliation: Neutral Theme: Drums (Ganker, Meathead) Strength: 28 + (3.2) Agility: 12 + (1.2) Intelligence: 18 + (1.8) Health: 682 Mana: 234 Damage: 46-58 Armor: 2 Range: 400 Movement speed: 295 Sight range: 1800/800 ICON SET ![]() ![]() SKILLS Branding (Single-target nuke, Self-heal) Thinning the Herd (Passive, Defensive) ![]() Drums of Vigor (Passive, Aura, Affects Allies) ![]() Rampage (Single Target Nuke, Disable) This suggestion template is completely mine. Some of the layout was inspired by Dark Kenshi's template. |

|
|
#2 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 846
|
OP,why u dont used this perfect ingame icon for 3rd skill?
__________________
Just try an' stop me!
|
|
|
|
#3 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2009
Posts: 40
|
First would like to start it off with this. This is an alternate icon for your ultimate. From WoW so up to you if you would like to use
. Skill 1: This is nice, and fits his theme well. Think this would be something different for DotA. Skill 2: Null. Maybe use something with his tail? Skill 3: This is actually pretty neat, I think it would be awesome if it did something along with the attack speed. Ultimate: This sort of reminds me of banes ultimate. Think it needs a bit of rework. I like the strength multiplier though. Skill 1: 3/3 Skill 2: Null Skill 3: 3/3 Ultimate: 0/1 Total 6/7. Pretty good from what I have seen so far, can't wait to see the last skill. Trying to get a good review for my hero on her passive remake and her new instant cast "Whip". Think you could lend a hand on reviewing the hero one more time? http://www.playdota.com/forums/14616...ly-lost-rider/ Thank you. |
|
|
|
#4 |
Member
|
Added Thinning the Herd for Skill 2.
Thank you ZED and Taztingo for icon suggestions. Both were used.
__________________
![]() [Arcane Sanctum] Magic's Vengeance: Want some extra damage for your caster late game? [Ancient of Wonders] Happy Fun-Time Bomb: It looks as if it's... smiling. [AGI-Sentinel] Nemosus, Nature's Fury: AoE, spell dependent cousin of Rooftrellen. [STR-Sentinel] Harpeia, Dust Witch: SHE'S BRINGING THE PAIN TRAIN. [STR-Neutral] Grok'tul, Warbringer: Tank with strength based spells and a nice passive. [INT-Sentinel] Astruma, Fallen Star: Very unique, astral based hero. [AGI-Neutral] Iuguolo, Caustic Cut-Throat: Acid based with unique passive. [INT-Scourge] Vexistrasz, Flame Aspect: Melee AoE nuker. Great synergy. |
|
|
|
#5 |
Banned
|
Hero review since you asked for one on the Carly topic (well not really from me, but eh)
Skill 1: Nifty version of Thunder Clap/Earthshock but loads more powerful. Mana Cost should increase per level, like 20~30 mana increase due to its huge AoE, huge slow, and massive damage potential. Skill 2: Neat concept but very broken atm. I mean if regular creeps attack him, he'll gain huge str bonuses and with an already absurd str growth of 3.2 and starting strength of 28 AND he's range. It's just not fair...not fair at all. I say +str after taking a set amount of damage. Maybe 100 or 150 should do it...otherwise you may be unkillable (taking in to account of other tank items like vanguard and importantly HoT). skill 3: Guessing if you keep attacking, you can keep getting that 50% AS buff very often since the duration of it is only 2 seconds. Nifty way to abuse your tanking ability and his attack range. Ultimate: Boo yah! Run over those scrubs like a war pounding maniac. Was gonna complain about the huge damage he could deal, but since it's physical I think it's actually okay. Overall: Meanest tank in the game and maybe TOO good as he carries a wide AoE slow, a stun, a ranged str, large str growth and large starting str. Basically I feel like it reeks of imbaness, but the concept is pretty good otherwise. Mind taking a look at Dar'Kurosky, Dark Sage? Or Remade Mok'Thran in my sig? Or Sidious, Sith Lord? Thanks and hope my review helped. |
|
|
| Last edited by kings.empire; 01-17-2010 at 02:46 AM. | |
|
|
#6 |
Member
|
Reworked Thinning the Herd again. Made its numbers a lot more reasonable for its effect.
__________________
![]() [Arcane Sanctum] Magic's Vengeance: Want some extra damage for your caster late game? [Ancient of Wonders] Happy Fun-Time Bomb: It looks as if it's... smiling. [AGI-Sentinel] Nemosus, Nature's Fury: AoE, spell dependent cousin of Rooftrellen. [STR-Sentinel] Harpeia, Dust Witch: SHE'S BRINGING THE PAIN TRAIN. [STR-Neutral] Grok'tul, Warbringer: Tank with strength based spells and a nice passive. [INT-Sentinel] Astruma, Fallen Star: Very unique, astral based hero. [AGI-Neutral] Iuguolo, Caustic Cut-Throat: Acid based with unique passive. [INT-Scourge] Vexistrasz, Flame Aspect: Melee AoE nuker. Great synergy. |
|
|
|
#7 |
Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 10
|
Kinda over imo...
I mean, he got a huge str gain p*lvl 3,2 plus the 2nd spell (that i really liked i must assume), and all his spells counts with a str* so, i mean his ult will easily deal (on lvl 3) 500 damage, AND 3 sec stun, with a cd of 50, manacost 225, Magna, for ex, deals 300, with a 100 sec cd, 300 mana cost 4 sec stun, and must be perfect landed, instead of just running around. imo, lower the damage, for a max of 3,5*, as well as lower the first skill *, raise the cd and manacost of the ulti. Nice hero btw. t-up |
|
|
|
#8 |
Member
Join Date: Dec 2009
Posts: 40
|
Sorry been busy, I will give a review now though.
Skill 1: This still a good skill, I am imaging this skill in the game. I think this would look nicely seeing the ground around him like tremble or shake as he moves. Skill 2: I like this skill too, but reminds me of Leviathan a bit. I think the amount of damage should be reworked a bit, maybe increase more. Skill 3: This is something new to dota. When I think of this i think of WoW. I feel that casters should get a reset cooldown on their normal spells instead of attack speed. It's up to you, but definitely is new. Ultimate 4: Just reminds me of a new weaver. Not too impressed with it, sorry. I know I'm going against myself, but at the same time I love how he is running over people .Skill 1: 3/3 Skill 2: 2/3 Skill 3: 3/3 Ultimate: 0/1 The idea is getting better and better, and your new ability fit right in with his theme. |
|
|
|
#9 |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Poland
Posts: 992
|
Only 1 thing I can say is that Grok'tul's ultimate reminds me of my Grothorned's ultimate.
Kinda reworked 'copy-pasta'. Just a though.
__________________
My Hero - Grothorned, The Kodo Rider!
[Now with a wonderful test map by Lord of theDing!] |
|
|
|
#10 |
Member
|
I've never seen your hero suggestion before, sorry about the similarities.
__________________
![]() [Arcane Sanctum] Magic's Vengeance: Want some extra damage for your caster late game? [Ancient of Wonders] Happy Fun-Time Bomb: It looks as if it's... smiling. [AGI-Sentinel] Nemosus, Nature's Fury: AoE, spell dependent cousin of Rooftrellen. [STR-Sentinel] Harpeia, Dust Witch: SHE'S BRINGING THE PAIN TRAIN. [STR-Neutral] Grok'tul, Warbringer: Tank with strength based spells and a nice passive. [INT-Sentinel] Astruma, Fallen Star: Very unique, astral based hero. [AGI-Neutral] Iuguolo, Caustic Cut-Throat: Acid based with unique passive. [INT-Scourge] Vexistrasz, Flame Aspect: Melee AoE nuker. Great synergy. |
|
|
|
#11 |
Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Somewhere in Asia
Posts: 1,965
|
I think this guy is really cool, i also love his model.
Does the ulti have stack damage if he runs into them? for example, you bash em twice in one bump? Wouldnt that be imba if you bash a guy in the corner multiple times? |
|
|
|
#12 |
Member
|
I've been meaning to add this, but I kept on forgetting. Damage and stun can only happen once from the ultimate. Running back over someone doesn't do more damage or stun again.
__________________
![]() [Arcane Sanctum] Magic's Vengeance: Want some extra damage for your caster late game? [Ancient of Wonders] Happy Fun-Time Bomb: It looks as if it's... smiling. [AGI-Sentinel] Nemosus, Nature's Fury: AoE, spell dependent cousin of Rooftrellen. [STR-Sentinel] Harpeia, Dust Witch: SHE'S BRINGING THE PAIN TRAIN. [STR-Neutral] Grok'tul, Warbringer: Tank with strength based spells and a nice passive. [INT-Sentinel] Astruma, Fallen Star: Very unique, astral based hero. [AGI-Neutral] Iuguolo, Caustic Cut-Throat: Acid based with unique passive. [INT-Scourge] Vexistrasz, Flame Aspect: Melee AoE nuker. Great synergy. |
|
|
|
#13 |
Member
|
Why don't you use this for the last skill? looks fairly better :P
from WC3 Rexxar's ulti.I like his Str based skills. Still, i think that there's no need for additional STR stacks on Thinning to not refresh duration. Even at lv4 he gets less HP boost from new STR that the damage dealt to him, so he'll end up dying :P I've done some rough numbers, and ulti seems to be doing little damage. Anyway, it's a devastating stun skill, so keep it that way! ^^ nice hero, nice theme. I always loved Kodo's skin for a hero suggestion, but never could get some nice idea for it. You did to me what i did to you on the Sludge :P jejeje again, nice work! ^^
__________________
|
|
|
|
#14 | |
Member
|
Quote:
For the Thinning not to stack, it is to prevent ridiculous tankage by him. He could just take damage from towers and creeps to become an unkillable machine for period of time. Also, it is supposed to still make him lose health because the point of this skill is to help beef him up a bit during a battle, making his active spells incredibly deadly if he is focused. The ultimate is similar to Obsidian Destroyer's. It will deal large damage if the player makes a strong strength item build (armlet, heart, etc.).
__________________
![]() [Arcane Sanctum] Magic's Vengeance: Want some extra damage for your caster late game? [Ancient of Wonders] Happy Fun-Time Bomb: It looks as if it's... smiling. [AGI-Sentinel] Nemosus, Nature's Fury: AoE, spell dependent cousin of Rooftrellen. [STR-Sentinel] Harpeia, Dust Witch: SHE'S BRINGING THE PAIN TRAIN. [STR-Neutral] Grok'tul, Warbringer: Tank with strength based spells and a nice passive. [INT-Sentinel] Astruma, Fallen Star: Very unique, astral based hero. [AGI-Neutral] Iuguolo, Caustic Cut-Throat: Acid based with unique passive. [INT-Scourge] Vexistrasz, Flame Aspect: Melee AoE nuker. Great synergy. |
|
|
|
|
#15 | |
Member
|
General Hero Idea: Very good, I like this model, original theme.
15/15 Firstly, please rework your skill layout, add damage and important information to levels and write Duration/MC/CD and other information below the level information, as it is done normally. Skill 1: Some fixes in description needed. Cast range is 0, AoE is 350/400/450/500. MC is way too high, make it maximally 125, but not higher. The skill isnt that strong. Overall, this is just a thunderclap which scales lategame, as its based on STR partitially. Nothing unique, not much originality in concept. Needs a remake. 2/10 Skill 2: Needs some more balance through its different levels. Firstly, the damage required to trigger this should be constantly 100 or sth like that. Then, Id scale the duration to 15/18/21/25 or something similar. 10 seconds at level 1 is pretty weak for having to receive 100 damage. Hmm, well the skill is okay. Its a bit bland needing to be damaged to receive more survivability with increased STR, but its as well cool, because he gets stronger and deals more damage as well. Could need a tiny tweak to be more interesting perhaps, but Im not that sure. One question: Does the temporary STR increase only your max HP or as well your current HP the moment you get it? 6/10 Skill 3: Duration 2 seconds? WTF? Having to attack 7 times to attack faster for 2 times is pretty lame. Well, heres my suggestion: The duration is permanent if you stay in the AoE of this aura. It lasts 1/2/3/4 seconds if you leave it. This makes it really hard for enemies, they cant really focus on Grok'tul, due to his second skill, but focusing on other enemies wouldnt be better either, as this aura would stay until the very end of the gank ^^ Apart from duration, really good and fun aura. 8/10 Ult: Some similarities with Shukuchi, though the differences predominate a bit. Still, imo you should change the phasing into a knockback to everything coming into his path, would be better fitting imo. Phase for such a huge kodo just looks awful ^^ 6/10 Synergies: Some nice synergies, especially skill 2 and 3 form an excelent combo, as it makes you a tank and at the same time enemies will have a hard time both if they attack you and if they attack your allies. Skill 1 doesnt synergize that good with the other skills, but okay. 16/20 Gameplay: 2 passives and a boring first skill is a bit lame atm, although the second passive is fun. Could need some improvements, but still its rather unique and original. 10/15 Stats: Balanced. 5/5 Model/Icons: Fine. 5/5 Overall: 73/100 = 73% Good hero suggestions, although some improvements should be made. Skill 1: Ive no idea yet, but it should be remade into something synergizing and suiting his playstyle. For skill 2: How about making it more interesting by adding a subskill, which deals damage to yourself (enough to trigger the STR icnrease) and then heals you for 2/3/4/5 times the damage? Would be great for tanking imo. Something like this:
|
|
|
|
|
#16 |
Member
|
This is my quote of your review. Made it easier for me to respond.
General Hero Idea: Thanks. Kodo model basically has to be a tank unless someone has a really unique idea. For the layout, that is really strange that I skipped AoE when I was making this. Thanks for pointing that out. Skill 1: Replacing this with your "Kodo Regeneration" except I will most likely rename it to something referring to battle or longevity. Your skill works fine on its own because it is like any other heal, except only for himself. He can chill in a lane forever as long as he has mana and doesn't get nuked down. Skill 2: Having it be 100 required damage for every level makes this skill ridiculously overpowered. He would do this at level 4: take 100 damage, gain 4 strength (72 health). That would make it so this guy isn't ever going to die unless the other team has some HUGE nuke capabilities. As for your question about how does the strength add to the health, it adds to current health like a small heal of 19 health per strength gained. Skill 3: So you want this to be a permanent 50% bonus attack speed aura? Kind of overpowered don't you think? Ultimate: It is supposed to be like a real stampede. A giant rhinoceros running over you isn't going to knock you back a few feet. It is going to ram you into the ground (stunning you). Synergies: The first skill and the ultimate are actually supposed to be the best synergy with the second skill. As you take damage you are increasing your strength, making your two spells cause massive damage. Gameplay: So your main problem is with the first skill? Stats: Alright. Model/Icons: Alright. For your suggested skill as I said, I will most likely be replacing skill 1 with it. I think that is a really good spell. The only problem I'll have with it is that it only would effect him. Making him only worth his ultimate and his second passive to his allies. But then again, you have heroes like SK who has 3 passives and only one of the passives effects allies. Thanks for the review. Hopefully you look back here soon.
__________________
![]() [Arcane Sanctum] Magic's Vengeance: Want some extra damage for your caster late game? [Ancient of Wonders] Happy Fun-Time Bomb: It looks as if it's... smiling. [AGI-Sentinel] Nemosus, Nature's Fury: AoE, spell dependent cousin of Rooftrellen. [STR-Sentinel] Harpeia, Dust Witch: SHE'S BRINGING THE PAIN TRAIN. [STR-Neutral] Grok'tul, Warbringer: Tank with strength based spells and a nice passive. [INT-Sentinel] Astruma, Fallen Star: Very unique, astral based hero. [AGI-Neutral] Iuguolo, Caustic Cut-Throat: Acid based with unique passive. [INT-Scourge] Vexistrasz, Flame Aspect: Melee AoE nuker. Great synergy. |
|
|
|
#17 | |||||||
Member
|
Quote:
![]() Quote:
Quote:
Each stack lasts 15 seconds or 2/3/4/5 seconds after you moved out of the AoE. It would be balanced, as it requires you to stay close to Grok'tul. As long as you stick close to him, the buff will last a pretty long time, meaning enemies will have to focus on Grok'tul if they want to remove it. Thats what makes him a stronger tank, it gives enemies a reason to attack him. Quote:
Well, but anyway, its pretty fine, but there are some minor similarities to Shukuchi. Quote:
Quote:
For skill 1 Id like something with STR, as said. Ill post again if I have an idea. Edit: Perhaps something like this:
|
|||||||
|
||||||||
| Last edited by JJE92; 02-28-2010 at 12:02 PM. | ||||||||
|
|
#18 |
Member
|
Thanks for the new skill but I reworked your original suggestion into being a non-selfish skill. Tell me what you think. Also, I reworked Drums of Vigor.
__________________
![]() [Arcane Sanctum] Magic's Vengeance: Want some extra damage for your caster late game? [Ancient of Wonders] Happy Fun-Time Bomb: It looks as if it's... smiling. [AGI-Sentinel] Nemosus, Nature's Fury: AoE, spell dependent cousin of Rooftrellen. [STR-Sentinel] Harpeia, Dust Witch: SHE'S BRINGING THE PAIN TRAIN. [STR-Neutral] Grok'tul, Warbringer: Tank with strength based spells and a nice passive. [INT-Sentinel] Astruma, Fallen Star: Very unique, astral based hero. [AGI-Neutral] Iuguolo, Caustic Cut-Throat: Acid based with unique passive. [INT-Scourge] Vexistrasz, Flame Aspect: Melee AoE nuker. Great synergy. |
|
|
|
#19 |
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 36
|
Skill 1:
First of all, i really like the name of this skill, it both fits the theme, and it's quite funny to imagine. The damage seems a little low when you compare the cooldown and manacost to other known spells, like stormbolt, dragonslave etc. which also are ranged, i think you can buff it a bit without anyone being offended. The heal part is also well thought out. It synergices with his damage "eating" and it allows for healing over time when escaping. Overall i like it. Just one question, is it possible to cast it while moving (synergy with ultimate). Skill 2: Not so much more to say about this skill. I believe it would work, great damage soaking, which allows for more damage soaking. The duration also seems resonable. Long enough to last for a battle or medium to heavy harrasment, but runs out "quickly" too in unrelated situations. Skill 3: I think this skill is the one I like the least. It fits the drummer theme sure, but its just not that usefull in combat imo. When fighting larger fights he will often be in front of the rest of the team, aggroing, thus he is too far from them for the aura to take effect, and it doesnt synergy with any of the skills. The ulti just brings him farther from his allies when trying to stun as many as possible. And when youre chasing, it isn't the attackspeed that counts, but the movement speed. Skill 4: Just great. Stampede through the ranks of your enemies while your strength rises due to the aura, giving your ultimate even more of a punch. Not much more to say, very versatile in most combat situations and cooldown and damage seems reasonable. In all I really like this hero. But there are two things i believe you should change: 1. I dont see why you have made him a ranged hero. He got two skills that requires him at melee range. 2. The third skill could use a remake, maybe to something completly different, perhaps something that fits a melee frontfighter? Ill be coming back later to see your response. /h0vSa
__________________
|
|
|
|
#20 |
Member
|
The main reason he has skill 3 as it is, is to be somewhat useful to the team besides taking damage. He is a ranged hero because I'm sick of Huskar being the only ranged strength hero. Huskar also has a melee range skill (his ultimate) so I don't think it really means anything that he should have ranged skills. For Branding to even make sense he needs it to be melee.
If you want a good reasoning behind skill 3 look at JJE92's first response (the review). It explains that skill 2 makes it so that you don't want to attack him unless you are going straight for the kill while skill 3 makes it so you want to attack him to get rid of that aura. Being 400 range makes his aura spread to melee and longer ranged units so his entire team receives the bonus. Thanks for the review.
__________________
![]() [Arcane Sanctum] Magic's Vengeance: Want some extra damage for your caster late game? [Ancient of Wonders] Happy Fun-Time Bomb: It looks as if it's... smiling. [AGI-Sentinel] Nemosus, Nature's Fury: AoE, spell dependent cousin of Rooftrellen. [STR-Sentinel] Harpeia, Dust Witch: SHE'S BRINGING THE PAIN TRAIN. [STR-Neutral] Grok'tul, Warbringer: Tank with strength based spells and a nice passive. [INT-Sentinel] Astruma, Fallen Star: Very unique, astral based hero. [AGI-Neutral] Iuguolo, Caustic Cut-Throat: Acid based with unique passive. [INT-Scourge] Vexistrasz, Flame Aspect: Melee AoE nuker. Great synergy. |
|