|
|
#1 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Member
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Hero | Role | Other Roles | Banned? | Picked? | Pop | Guide |
| Initiate | Gank, AoE | Auto / Always | 1st Picked | n/a | ||
| Carry | Gank | Auto / Always | 1st Picked | n/a | ||
| Roam | Rune & Lane Control | Always | 1st Picked | . | ||
| Tank | Initiator, Anti-Push | Always | 1st Picked | . | ||
| Support | Initiate, Carry | Very Likely | 1st Picked | . | ||
| Carry | Push, Disable | Very Likely | 1st Picked | . | ||
| Roam | Disable, Heal, Ward | Very Likely | Verly Likely | . | ||
| Roam | Rune & Map Control | Very Likely | Very Likely | + | Zan's | |
| Semi-Carry | Tank, Babysitter | Very Likely | Very Likely | + | ||
| Carry | Roam, Anti-Chen, Tank | Very Likely | Very Likely | + | Bergson | |
| Debuff | Heal, Ward | Likely | Very Likely | + | Vindicate | |
| Roam | Gank, Anti Push | Likely | Likely | + | ||
| Gank | AoE | Sometimes | Always | . | Merlini | |
| Roam | Initiate, Ward | Rarely | Always | . | ||
| Semi-Carry | Roam, Initiate | Sometimes | Likely | . | ||
| Carry | Gank | Sometimes | Likely | + | ||
| Initiate | Gank | Rarely | Always | . | ||
| Tank | Initiate | Sometimes | Sometimes | - | ||
| Gank | Disable, Initiate | Sometimes | Likely | - | Noobish-Noob | |
| Babysitter | AoE, Anti-Death, Ward | Rarely | Sometimes | + | ||
| Babysitter | Ward, Gank, Mana | Sometimes | Likely | - | ||
| Carry | Gank | Rarely | Sometimes | - | ||
| Carry | Initiate, Gank | Sometimes | Likely | - | ||
| Carry | Support, Anti-Tank | Sometimes | Sometimes | - | ||
| Carry | Gank, Anti-Blink | Rarely | Sometimes | - | ||
| Carry | Tank, Anti-Combo | Rarely | Sometimes | + | ||
| Carry | Gank, Anti Blink | Rarely | Sometimes | + | ||
| Carry | Lane Control, Roam, Tank | Depends | Depends | . | ||
| Roam | Disable, AoE | Sometimes | Sometimes | - | ||
| Babysitter | Initiate, Semi-Carry | Never | Sometimes | . | ||
| Semi-Carry | Gank, Map Control | Never | Sometimes | . | ||
| Roam | AoE, Anti-Fog | Rarely | Situational | + | ||
| Carry | Gank, Map Control | Sometimes | Situational | + | ||
| Semi-Carry | Gank, AOE | Never | Situational | + | ||
| Support | Disable, Ward | Sometimes | Sometimes | - | DarkMedina | |
| Semi-Carry | Anti Invis, Initiate | Never | Sometimes | + | EcceLex's | |
| Gank | Ward | Never | Situational | . | ||
| Push | Carry | Rarely | Situational | - | ||
| Carry | Push, Tank | Never | Situational | - | ||
| Support | Push, Mana | Rarely | Situational | - | ||
| Carry | Tank | Never | Experimental | + | ||
| Carry | Push | Never | Experimental | + | ||
| Support | AoE, Ward | Never | Situational | . | ||
| Initiate | Tank, Disable | Never | Situational | . | ||
| Initiate | Roam, Ward | Never | Sometimes | . | ||
| Gank | Roam, AoE | Never | Rarely | . | ||
| Roam | Carry | Never | Experimental | + | ||
| Roam | Initiate, Ward | Never | Rarely | + | ||
| Gank | Ward | Never | Situational | ? | ||
| Carry | AoE | Never | Rarely | . | ||
| Carry | Gank | Never | Sometimes | . | ||
| Carry | Pusher | Never | Situational | . | ||
| Semi-Carry | Tank, Map Control | Rarely | Situational | . | ||
| Carry | Gank | Rarely | Experimental | + | ||
| Carry | Roam, Push | Rarely | Rarely | . | ||
| Initiate | Never | Rarely | . | |||
| Carry | Chaser | Never | Situational | . | ||
| Carry | Tank, AoE | Never | Rarely | . | ||
| Support | Debuff | Never | Situational | - |
|
|
#2 |
Member
|
Necro has been nerfed really bad now. He's so much fragile on 6.61b.
Tinker is also an anti-blinkers. PotM is more like a ganker. Would never be a carry. Viper can be built as a semi-carry, as a tanker or as a supporter. I've seen support Vipers win games by themselves. Puck is more like a support. Okay as Ganker and initiator too, meh Disabler. He's a good wardbitch. SK is a good initiator too, but can't do everything by himself as ES. Zeus is a ganker, also can be used to support with Guinsoo and wards. Enigma can be used to initiate and ofc disable. Bane IS a carry. Disables, initiates, carries. Warlock is a natural initiator. Coupled with Axe or SK, he can be gamebreaking. Beastmaster is a ganker, semi-carry. Bloodseeker is a situational pick. Built as a carry. QoP is an AOE bitch. Meepo jungling? In competitive play? DK tanks. Razor ganks very well. Lich initiates. WD supports. Tidehunter tanks and ganks. Lina supports like Lion. Pandaren is a natural carry. Also tanks. Broodmother isn't used to give vision. Wards are. Some typos. Experimental = Potential competitive heroes that ARE being tested. Need some SF, Morphling, Lanaya, Juggernaut, Vengeful, Furion, Storm, Leshrac, DarkSeer, Destroyer, Pugna, Tiny, Alchemist, Doom and Pit Lord in this thread.
__________________
|
|
|
|
#3 |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 122
|
Tide never banned?... seriously
|
|
|
|
#4 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: UW Madison, WI, USA
Posts: 475
|
I wouldn't exactly qualify Rhasta as a carry either. If pushing to hell makes you a carry, we're using a different definition of carry. Cuz Rhasta isn't going to be slamming through 3 enemies and wtfroflsaucing ppl like Necro and DP can (the other Int "carries"). Do you farm Rhasta a ton of gold? How does that build go?
Also just as a suggestion, some formatting here (either into tiers or roles). Otherwise good lookin' guide, nice to have also
__________________
![]() ![]() Now Playing: MW2 and League of Legends Don't know about LoL? It's a great successor to DotA! Signup Here! My username is FrozenStorm there ^^ Check out my Slardar Guide in Progress Archive of the Outpicked Game Bio / Introduction Page (with pictures ^^) |
|
|
|
#5 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 3,045
|
To begin with their roles are fucked up. I mean c'mon Mirana carry? She's semi-carry at best and thats a secondary role, her main role is ganker as well as initiator. Akasha is pure ganking/AoE presence as well, she isn't even a semi-carry. Also, Axe carry? Are you kidding? He's a powerful tank/initiator for god's sake.
Do you even know the meaning of a carry? Also, Bat is exceptional at ganking and has a strong lane presence as well. I'd list him as a ganker/support. Also, you should've understood by now that TC is an all around powerhouse being valid for semi-carrying but mostly initiating/ganking. Razor fits ganking more than carrying but he is valid for it. Also Brood is most importantly a pusher rather than a carry. BS is a fucking awesome ganker that has potentially the most potent lane-staying out of all melee heroes with minor regeneration items required. Beastmaster should be listed as a ganker/initiator/ward destroyer. Also I'd rather list Dirge as a powerful/rigged supporter since he prepares the enemy team to die for his team (slowing zombies, amplifying damage, aoe hp decrease) as well tanking for them (self heal through unit death etc.). Also, you should note that both Kunkka and Nai'x are capable of ganking, Kunkka is also one of the most potent initiators out there. e: why is this in draft guides?
__________________
98% of people have no idea of mechanics, if you are one of the 2% nerds put this in your sig
|
|
|
|
#6 | ||||||||
Member
|
Quote:
I asked and explained his role in the thread, hopefully you can take a look and maybe get an understanding of why I considering him as a carry. Formatting --> will come later as I wrote this just now and trying to get suggestions to filling in the blanks. Maybe give me ideas to how to sort them. Quote:
Axe, maybe I should have said tanker. I have seen carry axes, but not in 6.60. I've watch several replays in 6.5x that he goes radiance. and get his tank items. If there is an Axe that managed to get hood, vanguard, blink, heart, phase boots and becomes unkillable while killing everyone, what would u consider him a carry at this point? or call him a tank that kills everyone? Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Dirge --> I see what you mean. What I listed isn't set in stone. Cuz I was thinking bloodstone = carry hero, I guess he *might* be the exception. Quote:
Quote:
not much in the euro / NA metagame, he is picked and banned more often in mid / high level. I don't watch the asian metagame. |
||||||||
|
|
|
#7 |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Vancouver, BC
Posts: 52
|
How about Nevermore? Great carry IMO.
|
|
|
|
#8 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 801
|
Situational hero. He's a momentum hero; he either carries really hard or sucks really hard
__________________
[/QUOTE]
|
|
|
|
#9 |
Member
|
help me fill out the blanks asian, and correct whatever you think is wrong :P
|
|
|
|
#10 |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Indonesia
Posts: 19
|
-i believe that rhasta isn't a carry, more better to classified to pusher or disable heroes. but not a carry IMO.
-chen is a top ban or top pick. great asset for turtle strategy[watch ravens replay] -batrider more likely is a ganker heroes.and he give great DPS too. is batrider a carry? maybe. but it is in grey area so it's still a bit confusing.semi carry better term for him -viper is a great hero this ver. the buff make him really sick. classified to first pick or top ban heroes IMO. SF is a semi carry heroes. he fails hard when going to pure carry. |
|
|
|
#11 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 31
|
hi frens im jus a learner n Vindicate i find ur post very helpfull thanx for putting up this post.
but i hav some questions , beginner question/ noob questions : 1) how will rhasta / bele carry i cant understand - carries r those who will carry their team to victory after they farm their items rights ? --at best they can be awesome disablers n gankers. pls if u can gimme some replays as them as carry , hardly these days ever see rhasta n bele in picks , they always banned. |
|
|
|
#12 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 801
|
Pandaren Brewmaster=initiator
Blink stop split cyclone stun and watch the pewn Dirge=tanker, initiator Broodmother=/= maphack, His webs cant even see runes even if theyre placed directly under, unless its daylight Razor doesn't really seem to fit into the carry role to me, semi-carry at best Lich-warder Meepo-carry; never banned unless you're playing against chu situational bat-carry from the games i've seen always banned or f/p and I expect BB to be very common in the next couple of months :P
__________________
[/QUOTE]
|
|
|
|
#13 | ||||||||
Member
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
||||||||
|
|||||||||
| Last edited by Vindicate; 08-07-2009 at 04:46 AM. | |||||||||
|
|
#14 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 2,267
|
Rhasta = carry??????? wtf are you high on. Also Phase Boots > serpent wards
|
|
|
|
#15 |
Member
|
He's a carry in the sense of Krobelus or Necrolyte, a spell carry if you will. His ult really wrecks a team fights and towers too, in fact an Aghanim'd Refreshered Wards is game breaking for the racks. Serpent Wards aren't used so much anymore to trap. It is an AoE spell and has a lot of potential with that. Shackles and Voodoo keep an opponent in ward range as well.
__________________
thanks to Francis for the sig
|
|
|
|
#16 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 20
|
Magnus? really? As much as I love magnus(he's my very first hero) I can't remember seeing him picked ever since 6.60 came out(although I always wanted to)..
And Dark Seer,IHMO one of the best heroes today, is missing. He can fill every role imaginable. Semi Carry,Pseudo tank,Initiator, Ass saver, support,pusher and Ganker. |
|
|
|
#17 |
Member
|
Good list, and I'm not sure I have any major criticisms. I'll just go through each hero and give you my thoughts on your analysis.
Rhasta - Not a carry, just huge support / pushing. Definitely a first pick or ban though. N'aix - agree Admiral - agree Necro - agree Tinker - definitely not a carry anymore since the BKB change, semi-carry is possible, definitely heavy support / ganker early Silencer kind of blows. Spectre - being picked again, so I am led to believe, although I'd love to see a replay. Morph - agree although what does it "depend" on? Axe - agree TC - role isn't important, he's autoban Batrider - also autoban CW - agree but what does it depend on NA - agree PotM - don't think she's "always" picked, maybe "likely." What's the difference between Roamer and Ganker in your list? Viper - agree Undying - lolwut? Puck - agree, very powerful hero Ench - agree SK - agree ES - agree Zeus - agree Enig - agree, is jungle covered in roaming? Chen - agree Lion - agree Bane / Warlock / Dazzle / Rylai - agree, CM is Team Void Stone role imo BM - ganker LoA, Veno, BS, QoP - agree, QoP is never banned, rarely picked imo Mostly agree or don't care about the rest as we're getting into lower quality heroes. Leviathan is Sometimes picked not Rarely imo. Brood is OFTEN picked or banned...unless there are changes I don't know about in .61 vs. .59? Krob is sometimes picked / banned, more than rarely unless I mistake much.
__________________
![]() ~ Visit My Pudge Guide ~ 98% of the forum puts stupid shit like this in their signatures. If you're one of the 2% that doesn't, put this in your signature. |
|
|
|
#18 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 59
|
@TS
great guide! needs tweaking but definitely it will have a use here ![]() my 2cents. i think sorting out the definition of a carry is a first for this guide (for myself, i only use the word carry for heroes who are made to slice 5 heroes in his path with the right items: ex. void, pa, spectre, troll). almost every hero can be played as a carry with the right items, but before they reached the "carry potential" they all serve some use 1st right? (ganker, initiator, tank, aoe nuker, nuker, disabler) ^this also applies to gankers. everybody can gank but it is the hero-theme that enables us to tell if they are a ganker or not. Ex. in your list. spectre is a ganker..yes she is with her global ulti. but think all of her skills.. dagger (for chasing), desolate (for killing solo heroes), dispersion (tanking ability for an agility type), then her ultimate. i think dispersion made her a carry, and ganking is one of her uses. that's why necro and dp can be carry with the right items, but before they go to that state.. what kind of hero are they? my ans: necro=support, pusher and dp= support, pusher just my 2cents. |
|
|
| Last edited by kitty04; 08-07-2009 at 05:35 AM. | |
|
|
#19 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,588
|
There needs to be distinguishing categories; there are plenty of very situational picks listed while some more viable heroes than them were left out.
|
|
|
|
#20 |
Banned
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,137
|
PotM is literally picked every serious game. I see occasional IDEC replay where she isn't used, but go through Pick League or DH or ANYTHING matches from leagues/tournaments and she'll be in every game.
|
|