Re: Suggestions forum discussion: Layout
Forgot to put this in:
^should THIS be used...
All recent suggestions newer than 3 months,
would go under this.
The older ones would go into an Archives
Worhty/popular/just plain good
suggestions would be systematically
worked back into the 'filing system' by
mods, or revived by fans of the particular
For my part, there could be THREE forums
First is a concept discussions forums, where
you post the core concept of your idea.
With no or at least, minimal numbers.
Here, people can go wild all they want.
Also, here you try to get other people who
like and support your idea, and who would
want to help work on it, so that it turns into
a group effort.
Since currently, I see someone opening up a
suggsestion for e.g a visual, and people
comment on it and gives input, and in most
of the cases, even if the viewers'
suggestions are clearly better than the
suggestor's, they just ignore/dismiss it.
If I were IceFrog, I'd rather implement
something made by a group of skilled
people, than by a single person.
after the bad, just plain wrong, already
suggested stuff has weeded out by above
mentioned process, and after a suggestion
has been fairly fine-tuned, it moves over to
the DISCUSSIONS section.
At this point, there should be very little, if
any plain dislikes(t-downs).
Key here is, to discuss and improve what is
Just like the current suggestions forum,
without all the flaming, demeaning, rude
and disrespectful comments.
Also, before they enter the discussion
forum, it needs to have been viewed by
After a while, a certain suggestion, that
seems especially unique/promising, it could
be added here.
This list remains closed to non-forum staff
This is the part where IFrog and his dev
team, and people actually in charge, gets to
view and discuss stuff.
This would be especially good for heroes,
items and abilities.
i.e only the best of the best would be sent