|
|
#1 |
Member
|
|
| Last edited by FlamingFist; 10-22-2009 at 10:38 AM. Reason: some clarifications | |
|
|
#2 |
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 31
|
Nice new concepts
but he needs to be reviewed more t-up for now |
|
|
#3 |
Member
|
king_james mini-review coming!!!!!!!
Clarifications on the first skill... is this autocast? Or is it a target cast with the attack? 2nd skill is quite similar, is it autocast too? The pure damage seems like night_sky95's Hammerspark hero. But I like how its not too imbalanced. 3rd skill is Storm Bolt with a mini-stun instead of the 2 sec stun. This needs a fix.Hammer Overload is incredibly strong. I like how you incorporate the 1st and 2nd skill, but this needs some more explanation. If they are only to last for 1 attack (the 1st/2nd skill), then how will you be able to pull this one off? Overall, good hero, concept is great, we need another Lightning-oriented dude, haha. Thor fits him well, and I'll be creating you a story soon... ![]() king_james |
|
|
#4 |
Member
Join Date: Jun 2009
Posts: 29
|
ok ok Real_Crime is going to give you a review
skills 1 and 2 - I like these 2 but what I like you to do is to make it like the 3rd skill of morphling where in when you level skill1 you will be given 2 skills w/c is negative and positive charge get what i mean, thus giving you the opportunity to make another skill for your hero skill 3 - Love the icon but i dont like the skill itself for me its like revised storm bolt. This need rework well if you want suggestion then tell me i have a great idea for this. skill 4 - Ok your explanation needs work. Is this AOE? well if yes then ok but if not then you should make it an AOE. - Ok i have a great idea how about make your last skill depend on your negative or positive charge. example: 1. you used positive charge then more damage but reduced slow 2. you used negative charge then more slow but reduced damaged |
|
|
#5 |
Member
|
The concept is good. But, Thor is name of god in viking myth. A very huge giant with a great hammer like paladin in wc3. He should be a str hero. But, it's no matter.
Positive and Negative charge maybe should change into Proton and Electron charge. Ulti needs some nerf. Third skill must be rework. Throw a hammer? sounded same like storm bolt of sven.
__________________
|
|
|
#7 |
Member
|
Skill 2: need more dmg range every level. I mean from 30/35/40/45 dmg to 15/25/35/45 dmg. This will make a significant effect.
Skill 3: where is duration? And 200 aoe is too small aoe. I suggest you increase it a bit. Skill 4: duration is too long. When u using negative charge, it make your enemy cannot escape and your team very easily to whack them.
__________________
|
|
|
#8 |
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Philippines
Posts: 54
|
Thor was a character in the Norse Mythology. The + and - charge should have its name changed. Compare it to an atom's parts. + is proton, - electron and the neutral is of course, Neutron. I hope you can get names from the atom's parts.
|
|
|
#9 |
Member
|
I think the hero is going into a nice direction. The concept still needs a lot of furnishing but its very promising.
The problems I see: • Everything's overly simplistic. There's nothing really too great. Lacks flavor. We're not really seeing something new and interesting • Lacks synergy. I'll assume that when you use first skill, you cancel the second one. The only synergy we have is forced, not that its bad, especially in this case because that defines this hero's gameplay, but really x.x. Needs more work.
__________________
Hi, I'm new here. Hope people could help me out start a new suggestion!
|
|
|
#10 |
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 31
|
nc new concepts, need more review
maybe ulti too weak |
|
|
#11 |
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 31
|
nc hero
few more works and he'll be fine needs more reviews from pros but for me he's ok main problem is skill synergy not very good |
|
|
#12 |
Member
|
My third check up:
* Hero information: - need story (make it by ur self or ask someone to make it for you) - lack hp until the end, worse than dwarven sniper (increase str growth gain). - Increase attack range (300 was too short for lightning god. Even zeus who is oldman have more attack range) - add synergy of skill, heroes and item (Make it when you think this hero no need big change anymore). * Skill 1: - Well, this skill provide more dmg of your skill. Fine. - Both charge need a tweak. Both have over great power since Lv1. (my suggest is from 30/35/40/45 to 10/20/35/45) - Where is duration of slow? (Don't make it 5 second, it shall be overpowered). - Damage type is? (physical/magical/pure). * Skill 2: - Remake it, please! You have slow disabler one, you don't need two. (Always make an alternative skill for "emergency" state). * Skill 3: - When electron charge has lv4 and overload has lv1, it will be nonsense when you must spend more mana for smaller slow effect instead spend less mana for bigger slow effect. (Make it deal bonus dmg or slow). - Once again, where is duration for slow effect? * Ultimate: - Reduce cooldown (300 is a film?? I mean 300 second was too long. 150 sec makes it sense) - Maybe need extra buff (Coz dmg only was too plain skill.) I wish you a good luck.
__________________
|
|
|
#13 |
Member
|
nice hero... but you shldnt write the items built here...
items built is depend on how the game goes...................................... THUMBS-UP rate 9.2/10 |
|
|
#14 |
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 31
|
nc edits and needs a lots a review
far from finish |
|
|
#15 |
Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Frieza Planet 419, because nobody ever goes to Frieza Planet 419
Posts: 16,647
Blog Entries: 6
|
OMG. A hero with full skillset synergy :O I love this guy. The Electron/Proton concept is very clever.
9.5/10 I would give 10/10 but since he's not implemented, cannot be totally sure of the balances. Aside from this, if my mods had heroes half as good as this guy I woudl be doing wel XD. Good job! |
|
|
#16 | |
Banned
|
Quote:
Anyways, what happens if you don't learn this skill. What would Lightning Overload do instead? Static Shock sounds stupid, I mean who would get that?! I mean, you evade an attack only to get stunned for 2 seconds!?!? I'm pretty sure you mean they'll get stunned for 2 seconds once they dodge the attack or something...making it very similar to craggy except no damage and you slow yourself. Ultimate is just one big nuke? That's...kind of...boring... Overall still needs some work on it, like the concept of proton and electron however I think effects may need to be altered a bit. |
|
|
|
#17 |
Member
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 104
|
Aghanim's Scepter only upgrades level 3 to level 4? :O so what if you have ulti at lvl 1. Fix the description man..
|
|
|
#19 |
Member
|
Re-review 2. As per request story later.
Please explain Lightning mark. A passive within a passive of two? Its quite confusing. How about like this, it has a 50/50 chance to gain bonus damage or trigger a slow, that would be great (electron/proton). Static Shock is more of a debuff than a buff, I like how you added magial attack (spells) to be evaded but I think the mana cost is too high and the cooldown too. Lower them. Ok skill for me. Lightning Overload... Wait wasn't the electron/proton on the 1st skill or wha? You didn't explain it well, is it an AOE skill or what. The mana cost and cd is too high too. Kinda like a storm bolt, but with a slow and no stun. Last skill is a Waning rift without the side effects turned into a pure damage. Its quite dull, I might say. Needs a change to live up to the gryphon model. Overall, you have some terrific concepts, just bad execution. You could have used the proton/electron in a more acceptable manner, not that it isn't its just out of place. Fix your tool-tips, fix some cooldown/mana statistics and make more explanations for your hero, all seems a little out of place. PM me if you have any concerns about my review. Good luck to your hero. ![]() king_james |
|
|
#20 |
Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 358
|
Just a few little things:
Static Charge: Slows you for 20/15/10/15(???? wtf) typos maybe. i like 1st and 2nd skill 3rd is a bit... hmm nja. 1st skill does proton dmg aslo get boosted by the skill? if yes it should be more like 10/20/30/40 dmg. Also your slow effects doesnt profit from the passive effect. I dont like the ulti its just too plain for me but maybe it synergyzes eh.Suggestions 1st skill Proton => Positron (A proton alone is a positive hydrogen atom, wich would immidiatly react with anything around, so you cant charge anything with it. A positron is a positive loaded electron.) 3rd skill. Make it a factor slow (factor 2/2.5/3/3.5). ber are no slows beside purge and medusa stone gaze with factor slows, also it fits to lightning, and its a bit more special. ulti.... dunno i would say remake, but i guess u like it ![]() greets |